Josh Kronfeld criticises loss of specialist openside flankers

Former All Blacks flanker Josh Kronfeld believes the evolution of rugby tactics has led to the decline of the specialist openside flanker. The former player, who earned 54 Test caps, argues that the modern game has moved away from the specific skills required for breakdown specialists.

Kronfeld suggests this shift began with a change in attacking philosophy. He noted that while the 1990s focused on passing before contact to change lines of attack, the arrival of players like Jonah Lomu shifted the focus toward powerful midfielders. He identified Tana Umaga, Ma’a Nonu, and Sonny Bill Williams as part of a trend toward big ball-carrying centres and second fives.

This emphasis on a heavy midfield dynamic has altered the requirements for the back row. Kronfeld claims that loose forwards are now primarily valued for ball retention at the breakdown, leading to a lack of distinction between the numbers six, seven, and eight. He believes the era of the specialist has ended, particularly within New Zealand rugby.

The former flanker cited the omission of Du’Plessis Kirifi from Dave Rennie’s All Blacks squad for the tour of South Africa as evidence of this trend. Despite a strong season with the Hurricanes, Kirifi was left out because he is a specialist openside who did not fit the coach's preference for versatile loose forwards who can move across the back row.

Kronfeld also commented on Luke Jacobson, describing him as an exceptional player with high statistics for ruck clear-outs and breakdown work. While acknowledging Jacobson's ability to play anywhere in the back row, Kronfeld expressed frustration at seeing him deployed at openside flank against the Stormers in Cape Town, noting he is not a typical specialist in that position.